Electric and gas cars are no longer living in separate universes. In 2024, about 9% of new U.S. vehicle registrations were electric, while the other 91% were still running on gasoline or diesel. That means you’re shopping in a mixed world where incentives, charging access, fuel prices, and resale value are all changing at once, and the “right” answer isn’t the same for everyone.
Quick take
Electric cars tend to win on energy and maintenance costs and local emissions, while gas cars still win on purchase price, refueling speed, and long-range convenience. The best choice depends on your driving pattern, living situation, and how long you’ll keep the car, especially in the used market.
Why electric and gas cars feel so different right now
Between 2020 and 2024, U.S. EV sales grew fast, but the story in 2025 is more complicated. New EVs now make up around 9–10% of retail registrations, but interest has cooled for some shoppers worried about charging access, politics, and upfront price. At the same time, used EV prices have fallen faster than used gas cars, creating some of the best value opportunities in the market, if you understand battery health.
Gasoline cars, meanwhile, are a known quantity. You can refuel almost anywhere in a few minutes, mechanics are easy to find, and incentives and regulations change more slowly. But gas prices are volatile, maintenance costs stack up over time, and tightening emissions rules in many states are pushing automakers toward electrification whether buyers are ready or not.
Electric and gas cars at a glance
Electric vs gas cars: core tradeoffs
Where each powertrain usually wins for everyday drivers
Electric cars (EVs)
Strengths
- Much lower fuel cost per mile if you charge at home
- Less routine maintenance (no oil changes, fewer moving parts)
- Instant torque and quiet, smooth driving
- Zero tailpipe emissions; cleaner overall in most regions
Typical pain points
- Higher upfront price (though used EVs can be bargains)
- Public fast charging can be inconsistent or crowded
- Home charging may require electrical upgrades
- Range shrinks in cold weather and at high speeds
Gas cars (ICE vehicles)
Strengths
- Lower purchase prices, especially new entry-level models
- Refuel in minutes almost anywhere
- Established service ecosystem everywhere
- Long range even in bad weather
Typical pain points
- Higher fuel costs per mile, especially if gas prices rise
- More routine maintenance over time
- Tailpipe emissions and potential future restrictions in some areas
- Stop-and-go traffic can feel less smooth and efficient
Electric and gas cars: the 2024–2025 snapshot
Total cost of ownership: EV vs gas
When you compare electric and gas cars, the sticker price only tells part of the story. What matters is total cost of ownership (TCO): purchase price (minus incentives) + energy/fuel + maintenance and repairs + insurance + depreciation over the years you’ll actually own the car.
Where the money goes: electric vs gas car ownership costs
How the major cost categories usually compare for similar-size electric and gas vehicles over ~5 years of ownership.
| Cost category | Electric car (EV) | Gas car (ICE) | What to watch |
|---|---|---|---|
| Purchase price | Higher, especially new; used prices dropping fast | Generally lower; more budget options | Check net price after tax credits and dealer discounts. |
| Fuel / energy | Lower if you charge at home; public fast charging can be pricey | Higher per mile; sensitive to gas price spikes | Look at your real commuting miles and local prices. |
| Maintenance | Lower; fewer wear items and fluids | Higher; oil, transmission service, exhaust, etc. | Ask for service history on any used gas car. |
| Repairs | Electronics and battery repairs can be expensive but infrequent | Wide range; more parts that can fail | Warranty coverage matters for both. |
| Depreciation | Can be steep, especially on early EVs and luxury models | More predictable; varies by brand | For used EVs, depreciation is already “baked in.” |
These are generalized patterns; specific models and local fuel/electricity prices can shift the outcome.
Think in dollars per year, not just sticker price
If an EV costs $4,000 more up front but saves you $900 a year on fuel and maintenance, it can break even in under 5 years. On the flip side, if you rely on expensive public fast charging and drive relatively little, a cheaper gas car, or a hybrid, can pencil out better.
Energy costs: electricity vs gasoline
If you can charge at home overnight on a standard residential rate, it’s common to spend the equivalent of $1–$1.50 per gallon in many parts of the U.S. Time-of-use rates and rooftop solar can drive that even lower.
Public DC fast charging is different. Pricing can reach parity with, or even exceed, gasoline on a per‑mile basis, especially if you pay per minute or use peak hours. If most of your charging will be public fast charging, the classic “EVs are always cheaper to fuel” story is less clear.
Maintenance and repairs
EVs eliminate oil changes, spark plugs, timing belts, exhaust systems, and complex multi‑gear transmissions. Over 5 years, that usually means hundreds to a few thousand dollars less in maintenance compared with a similar gas car.
On the gas side, long‑term ownership adds up: scheduled services, emissions components, and engine or transmission repairs as the miles climb. If you plan to drive 150,000 miles or more, the maintenance gap between electric and gas cars gets wider.
Watch for policy and incentive changes
Federal EV tax credits, state rebates, and even road‑use fees are in flux. Always check the latest rules for the specific model you’re considering and your income and location. The economics of electric and gas cars can change quickly when policy shifts.
Charging vs fueling: how the experience really compares
Even if the math works, your day‑to‑day experience with an electric car is defined by charging. For most owners who can plug in at home, that experience is genuinely better than visiting gas stations. For drivers who can’t easily install home charging, gas cars (or conventional hybrids) still have real advantages.
Charging vs fueling: daily reality
How electric and gas cars fit into real life for U.S. drivers
Home charging vs gas stations
- Home charging: You plug in at night and wake up with a "full tank" most mornings. No special trip to refuel, but you may need to install a Level 2 charger.
- Gas stations: Refilling takes 5 minutes, but you’re making a separate stop. There’s no equivalent of “refueling while you sleep.”
Road trips and long drives
- EVs: Great on predictable routes with fast chargers, but you’ll plan around charging locations and 20–40 minute stops.
- Gas cars: Any highway exit probably has fuel, and range is consistent in all weather. Better fit for remote regions today.
Cold weather and towing are different in EVs
If you live in a cold climate or tow frequently, expect shorter effective range in an EV than the EPA label suggests, sometimes by 20–40%. Gas vehicles also lose efficiency in the cold, but the impact on range is usually less dramatic and refueling is faster when you do run low.
Performance and driving experience
If you’ve only driven gas cars, the first thing you notice in an EV is the torque. Electric motors deliver their maximum twist from a standstill, so even ordinary EVs feel quick around town. There’s no gear hunting, almost no engine noise, and regenerative braking lets you slow the car with minimal pedal use.
Electric cars
- Instant acceleration: Great for merging and passing.
- One‑pedal driving: Regen braking can reduce fatigue in traffic.
- Low center of gravity: Battery pack in the floor improves stability.
- Quiet cabin: Less mechanical noise, more tire and wind noise at speed.
Gas cars
- More variation: Big difference between small economy engines and performance models.
- Refined at highway speeds: Good long‑distance comfort in many modern sedans and SUVs.
- Traditional feel: Familiar sound and response that some drivers simply prefer.
- Manual transmissions: If you still enjoy shifting your own gears, gas is your only option.
Visitors also read...
Where EVs are clearly better to drive
For many people, the best use case for an EV is daily commuting and city/suburban driving. If you drive 30–70 miles a day and can charge at home, the combination of quiet, smooth acceleration and never visiting a gas station is hard to beat.
Environmental impact and policy whiplash
Electric and gas cars have very different emissions profiles. EVs produce no tailpipe emissions, and even accounting for power‑plant emissions, they typically emit significantly less CO₂ over their lifetime than similar gas cars, especially as the grid adds more wind and solar. Gas cars, by definition, burn fuel and emit CO₂ and pollutants everywhere they’re driven.
Policy, however, has become volatile. Federal incentives have been tightened, relaxed, and re‑targeted more than once. Some states are pushing toward zero‑emission sales mandates, while others are actively discouraging EV subsidies and adding extra EV registration fees. That uncertainty doesn’t change the physics of emissions, but it can change the economics of electric and gas cars in your particular state.
Think lifetime emissions, not just tailpipe
Building any car, electric or gas, produces emissions. EVs front‑load more of that in battery production, but then emit little or nothing while driving. Gas cars have lower manufacturing emissions but increase their footprint every time you fill the tank. Over a typical lifetime, most EVs still come out ahead, especially when powered from cleaner grids.
Used electric and gas cars: where the real bargains are
If you’re comparing electric and gas cars today, the most interesting action is in the used market. Rapid EV depreciation, driven by fast technology improvements, shifting incentives, and buyer uncertainty, means you can often buy a used EV for far less than a comparable new model. Gas cars still hold value well, but that also means you pay more upfront.
Used EVs: big upside if the battery is healthy
- Lower prices: Many 3–5‑year‑old EVs sell for a fraction of their original MSRP.
- Lower running costs: You still get the energy and maintenance savings.
- Technology leap: Even older EVs feel modern in traffic thanks to instant torque and quiet operation.
The key risk is battery health. A degraded battery means reduced range and potentially expensive replacement down the line. That’s why transparent diagnostics, like the Recharged Score battery health report included with every EV we list, are critical before you commit.
Used gas cars: familiar but watch wear and tear
- Proven tech: Independent mechanics can service almost everything.
- Stable value: Depreciation patterns are well understood.
- Risk shifts to maintenance: High‑mileage engines and transmissions can surprise you with big repair bills.
For used gas cars, a strong service history and pre‑purchase inspection matter as much as the odometer reading. Deferred maintenance can erase any pricing advantage quickly.
How Recharged simplifies used EV shopping
Every EV on Recharged comes with a Recharged Score Report that includes verified battery health, fair market pricing, and expert guidance. That helps you compare used electric and gas cars on a more level playing field, especially if this is your first EV.
How to choose: electric, gas, or something in between
When people talk about “electric and gas cars,” they’re really talking about three different species: full EVs, full gas cars, and hybrids or plug‑in hybrids that live in between. Choosing among them is about matching the tech to your actual life rather than to a political tribe or a headline.
Three main powertrain paths
Use cases where each type of vehicle fits best
Battery electric vehicle (EV)
Best if:
- You can charge at home or at work.
- Your regular driving is under ~150 miles/day.
- You want low operating costs and smooth performance.
Think twice if: You road‑trip frequently in remote areas or depend on on‑street parking with no practical way to charge.
Gasoline vehicle
Best if:
- You live in a rural area with limited charging.
- You tow or haul often over long distances.
- You want the lowest upfront cost and fast refueling.
Think twice if: You have a long commute and high fuel bills; a hybrid or EV might save more over time.
Hybrid & plug‑in hybrid
Best if:
- You want better fuel economy but aren’t ready to rely on charging.
- You occasionally drive long distances but mostly stay local.
- You lack reliable home charging but can plug in sometimes.
Think twice if: You can install home charging and mostly drive predictable routes, at that point, a full EV may be simpler.
Be honest about your actual driving
Many drivers worry about the rare 600‑mile road trip and ignore the daily 40‑mile commute. If 90% of your miles are short trips around town, an EV or plug‑in hybrid can cover most of your life comfortably, even if you keep a gas car in the household for the occasional long haul.
Checklist: questions to answer before you pick a powertrain
Powertrain decision checklist
1. Where will you park and plug in?
If you have a private driveway or garage, installing a Level 2 charger can make an EV the most convenient option. If you rely on street parking or shared parking without outlets, a gas car or hybrid may be less stressful unless your building invests in charging.
2. How many miles do you drive per day?
Look at a typical week, not your wildest road trip. If you usually stay under 60–80 miles per day, even modest‑range EVs can work well. If you regularly do 200+ mile days with no time to charge, a gas car or long‑range hybrid is probably safer.
3. How often do you road‑trip?
A couple of long trips per year is one thing; weekly 400‑mile drives are another. For frequent long‑distance travel, prioritize fast‑charging coverage (for EVs) or stick with gas/hybrid for now.
4. What are fuel and electricity prices where you live?
Run rough numbers using your local gas price and electricity rate. In many areas, home‑charged EVs still win decisively on energy cost per mile, but if you’re stuck on expensive public charging, the equation changes.
5. How long will you keep the car?
The longer you keep a vehicle, the more important fuel and maintenance costs become relative to purchase price. EVs often make more sense for long‑term ownership; gas may look better for short leases or if you switch cars frequently.
6. Are you open to a used EV?
If the answer is yes, you can often get a lot more vehicle for the money. Just make sure you have clear, third‑party battery health data, like the Recharged Score, to avoid surprises.
FAQ: electric and gas cars
Frequently asked questions about electric and gas cars
Bottom line: electric and gas cars in 2025
Electric and gas cars are going to share the road for a long time. In 2025, EVs aren’t a universal upgrade or a doomed niche, they’re a powerful tool that makes the most sense when your daily driving, home setup, and time horizon line up with their strengths. Gas cars and hybrids still solve real problems particularly well: rural living, constant long‑distance driving, and the need for the lowest possible upfront cost.
If you’re EV‑curious but cautious, the used market is an excellent place to explore. Falling prices, better charging networks, and transparent battery diagnostics mean you can often get more car for your money than a comparable gas model, without betting your whole life on untested tech. And if you want help running the numbers on a specific EV versus a gas car you’re considering, Recharged’s specialists and battery‑health reports are there to make the tradeoffs clear before you sign anything.
