You’re not alone if you’re stuck on the fence about EV vs gas. In 2025, gas prices in the U.S. have eased to around $3.10 per gallon on average, while electricity costs have crept up to roughly 17–19¢ per kWh. That makes the math a lot less obvious than it was a few years ago. The good news: if you break ownership into fuel, maintenance, depreciation, and lifestyle, the picture becomes much clearer.
Quick takeaway
In 2025, EVs are typically cheaper to run day‑to‑day than gas cars, but they often cost more to buy and insure. The more you drive, and the more you can charge at home, the more an EV pulls ahead financially.
EV vs gas in 2025: the real story
EV vs gas by the numbers (2025 snapshots)
When you compare electric vs gas cars, you’re really comparing two different expense curves. Gas cars are generally cheaper up front, with well‑understood maintenance and fueling habits. EVs ask you to pay more on day one, but they pay you back over time with lower fuel and fewer moving parts to service. Whether that trade works in your favor depends heavily on how much you drive, your access to home charging, and whether you’re buying new or used.
Important context for 2025
Both gas and electricity prices have been volatile. Any calculator you see is a snapshot, not a promise. Always plug in your local gas price and power rate before making a decision.
Fuel and charging: what you’ll really spend
Typical EV charging cost
Let’s say you own an EV that averages 3.0 miles per kWh, a realistic figure for many compact and midsize models.
- Home electricity: ~18¢/kWh
- Energy per mile: 1 ÷ 3.0 kWh ≈ 0.33 kWh
- Cost per mile: about 6¢
If your local rate is closer to 14¢/kWh, that falls toward 4–5¢/mile; at 22–25¢/kWh, you creep toward 7–8¢/mile.
Typical gas fuel cost
Take a gasoline car that averages 30 mpg, which is common for many compact and midsize cars.
- Gas price: ~$3.10/gallon
- Energy per mile: 1 ÷ 30 gallon ≈ 0.033 gal
- Cost per mile: about 10–11¢
With a less efficient SUV at 22 mpg, you’re closer to 14¢/mile; a hybrid at 45–50 mpg can drop under 7¢/mile.
Rule of thumb
If you have reasonably priced home electricity and drive at least 10,000–12,000 miles per year, an EV will usually beat a similar gas car on fuel costs, even with gas at 2025’s relatively modest prices.
Fuel and charging scenarios: where EVs win and where gas still holds ground
Your personal costs depend heavily on how and where you refuel.
Mostly home charging
If you can plug in overnight at home, EVs are in their element.
- Lowest per‑mile costs
- No detours to station
- Great for commuters and families
Heavy fast‑charging use
Relying mainly on DC fast chargers, especially on expensive networks, narrows the gap.
- Per‑kWh rates can rival gas costs
- Still convenient on road trips
- But not ideal for daily charging
Gas car with good mpg
A small, efficient gas car or hybrid still has strong value.
- Low fuel cost per mile
- No charging logistics
- Stronger case if you drive few miles
Very rough fuel cost comparison (example)
Illustrative annual fuel costs for 12,000 miles of driving in 2025. Always plug in your own mpg, kWh/mile, and local prices.
| Vehicle type | Efficiency assumption | Energy price | Approx. fuel cost / year |
|---|---|---|---|
| Compact gas car | 30 mpg | $3.10/gal | $1,240 |
| Compact hybrid | 50 mpg | $3.10/gal | $744 |
| Compact EV (home charge) | 3.0 mi/kWh | 18¢/kWh | $720 |
| Compact EV (public fast charge mix) | 2.7 mi/kWh | 30¢/kWh blended | $1,333 |
These are estimates, not quotes. Your numbers will vary by vehicle, climate, and driving style.
Watch those public fast‑charge rates
On some premium fast‑charging networks, per‑kWh prices can be high enough that a big, inefficient gas car looks cheaper per mile, especially if you only drive occasionally. An EV without home charging can still work, but budget carefully.
Maintenance and repairs: which is cheaper to keep?
Here’s where EVs start to look very appealing. Electric drivetrains have far fewer moving parts than internal‑combustion engines. There’s no oil to change, no spark plugs, no exhaust system, no multi‑gear transmission. Tires, brakes, suspension, and cabin filters are still in play, but much of the traditional routine maintenance simply disappears.
Common maintenance: EV vs gas car
You still have to take care of an EV, but the checklist is shorter.
Gas car maintenance
- Regular oil and filter changes
- Transmission service
- Timing belts/chains (many engines)
- Exhaust components and catalytic converter
- Engine cooling system service
Over 8–10 years, these items add up to thousands of dollars, even if nothing major fails.
EV maintenance
- Tires (often wear a bit faster)
- Brake fluid and pads (pads last longer thanks to regen)
- Cabin air filter
- Coolant for battery/drive unit in some models
There’s less routine work, but specialized repairs can be expensive if they’re needed out of warranty.
What the cost studies show
Recent ownership studies find that EVs usually have significantly lower fuel and maintenance costs than comparable gas vehicles, even as gas prices have eased. The catch is that higher purchase price and insurance often offset some of those savings, especially for brand‑new EVs.
Independent shops vs dealer service
Not every independent shop is comfortable servicing EVs yet. Depending on where you live, you may be more tied to dealer service for high‑voltage or software issues, though routine items like tires and brakes are straightforward anywhere.
Upfront price, depreciation, and resale value
Ask any shopper: EV sticker prices still sting. New electric vehicles tend to be more expensive than similar gas models, and they can depreciate faster in the first few years because technology is improving so quickly and incentives change. That said, the used EV market looks very different, and often far more favorable.
Big money items in EV vs gas ownership
These are the major line items that drive total cost over 5–8 years of ownership.
| Category | EVs (typical) | Gas cars (typical) |
|---|---|---|
| Purchase price (new) | Higher than comparable gas; incentives help but vary | Usually lower for similar size and features |
| Purchase price (used) | Often excellent value; sharp 3–5 year depreciation | Depreciation more gradual; fewer bargain outliers |
| Depreciation | Fast in first 3–5 years; stabilizes later | More predictable, especially for mainstream models |
| Insurance | Often higher due to repair costs and vehicle price | More predictable; usually cheaper like‑for‑like |
| Resale desirability | Growing, especially for EVs with strong range and battery health | Well‑understood; depends on brand and fuel economy |
When you buy used, you let the first owner absorb steep depreciation, especially helpful for EVs.
Why used EVs can be a sweet spot
A 3–6‑year‑old EV with a healthy battery can deliver modern tech and ultra‑low running costs for the price of a much older or higher‑mileage gas car. This is where platforms like Recharged focus: verified battery health, transparent pricing, and expert guidance so you’re not guessing.
Reliability and battery health concerns
Reliability is where gas cars still have home‑field advantage, for now. Survey data in the last couple of years shows EVs reporting more problems on average than gas models, mostly around software glitches, infotainment issues, and teething problems from newer brands and models. The good news is that as the technology matures, the gap is shrinking.
- EV issues tend to be concentrated in newer, more complex models and startups still ironing out early designs.
- Traditional brands with simpler EVs often fare better than bleeding‑edge, feature‑loaded ones.
- Gas cars remain more predictable overall, simply because manufacturers have been building them for over a century.
Visitors also read...
The elephant in the room: battery degradation
Every lithium‑ion battery loses capacity slowly over time. Most modern EVs are holding up well, but a high‑mileage car with a poorly treated pack can have noticeably reduced range, and a replacement pack can be very expensive out of warranty.
How to judge battery health on a used EV
Don’t buy blind, treat the battery like an engine inspection.
Look at real‑world range
Compare the car’s current full‑charge range to its original EPA rating. A healthy used EV might be down 5–15%, not 30–40%.
Check service records
Frequent DC fast‑charging, years in extreme heat, or long periods sitting at 100% can accelerate degradation.
Ask for a battery health report
On Recharged, every car comes with a Recharged Score battery and health report so you know what you’re getting into before you sign anything.
Emissions and environmental impact
If you’re thinking EV vs gas for environmental reasons, the broad answer is simple: over their lifetimes, EVs almost always emit less greenhouse gas than comparable gas cars, even on electricity mixes that still include coal and natural gas. The details are where it gets interesting.
Where EVs win
- Tailpipe emissions: Zero. No CO₂, no NOx, no unburned fuel at the car.
- Upstream emissions: Power plants still emit, but grids are getting cleaner as renewables grow.
- High‑mileage drivers: The more you drive, the more you spread manufacturing emissions over clean miles.
Where gas still holds advantages
- Manufacturing footprint: EVs have a higher upfront carbon cost because of the battery.
- Clean electricity access: In regions with very dirty grids, the EV advantage is smaller (though usually still present).
- Battery materials: Mining and supply chains carry their own environmental and ethical questions.
Think lifetime, not just factory gate
Most independent analyses find that an EV "breaks even" on total emissions vs a similar gas car after tens of thousands of miles, then continues to pull ahead, especially in regions with cleaner electricity.
Lifestyle: charging vs fueling and road trips
On paper, EV vs gas comparisons are all numbers. In real life, it’s also about how you like to live. Some drivers fall in love with the plug‑in lifestyle and never want to see a gas station again. Others find public‑charging logistics maddening and go back to the pump with a sigh of relief.
Everyday life with EV vs gas
Same miles, very different routines.
Living with an EV
- Charge at home overnight; wake up with a "full tank" most days.
- Plan longer trips around public fast‑charging stops.
- Use apps to find chargers and monitor sessions.
- Weather and speed affect range more noticeably than in gas cars.
Living with a gas car
- Refuel in 5 minutes almost anywhere.
- Less planning for long trips.
- More regular visits to stations and quick‑lube shops.
- Fuel price swings hit your wallet directly.
If you road‑trip a lot, ask yourself these questions
1. How often do you drive 400+ miles in a day?
If it’s once or twice a year, an EV can handle it with some planning. If it’s every other weekend, a gas or hybrid might still be less hassle.
2. What’s charging like on your common routes?
Look at fast‑charging maps on your usual interstates. Dense coverage makes EV road‑tripping dramatically easier.
3. Can you live with 30–40 minute charging stops?
Some people love stretching their legs and grabbing coffee; others want a quick splash‑and‑go. Be honest about your patience level.
4. Will you share the car with less tech‑savvy drivers?
If family members are nervous about apps, chargers, or planning, you may want to ease into EV ownership or pair an EV with a gas car.
Consider a "two‑car solution"
Many households land on a sweet spot: one efficient gas or hybrid for long trips, one EV for commuting and errands. If you’re replacing just one car, think about which role it plays most often.
Who should choose EV vs gas (or wait)
Quick guide: who fits where?
Use this as a starting point, not a verdict.
Great EV candidates
- Daily commute under 60–80 miles
- Reliable overnight charging at home or work
- Drive 10,000+ miles/year
- Value quiet, quick acceleration, and tech features
Better off with gas or hybrid (for now)
- No home or workplace charging
- Frequently tow or haul heavy loads
- Live far from any public charging
- Want a simple, low‑tech ownership experience
When it’s smart to wait
- You’re happy with your current car
- Charging access is improving in your area
- New EV models with better range are on the horizon
- You want more clarity on incentives and regulations
How to narrow your choice in three steps
If you’re leaning EV
Check your average weekly mileage and whether you can reliably charge at home or work.
Estimate annual fuel vs charging costs using your local gas and electricity prices.
Shop used EVs with verified battery health to avoid early‑tech depreciation hits.
If you’re leaning gas or hybrid
Price out a high‑mpg gas car or hybrid against a comparable EV, not just purchase price, but fuel and maintenance.
Consider whether a used EV as a second car could cover most of your daily driving.
Revisit EV options in 1–2 years as charging networks and models expand.
How Recharged simplifies going electric
If you decide an EV fits your life better than a gas car, the next hurdle is finding one you can trust, especially on the used market. That’s where Recharged comes in. Recharged focuses on used electric vehicles and plug‑in hybrids, pairing each car with transparent data and expert support so you can shop with confidence instead of guesswork.
What you get when you shop for a used EV with Recharged
From battery health to financing, the process is built around EV ownership, not just any car sale.
Recharged Score & battery diagnostics
Every vehicle comes with a Recharged Score Report that includes verified battery health, fair market pricing, and condition details. You’re not just taking someone’s word for it, you see how the car has actually aged.
Financing, trade‑ins, and delivery
Recharged offers EV‑friendly financing options, trade‑in or consignment for your current car (gas or electric), and nationwide delivery. You can shop, finance, and complete paperwork entirely online, or visit the Experience Center in Richmond, VA if you prefer an in‑person walkthrough.
Designed for first‑time EV owners
If you’re coming out of a lifetime of gas cars, you don’t have to navigate EV jargon alone. Recharged’s EV specialists can walk you through range needs, home charging, battery health, and which models fit your lifestyle and budget.
EV vs gas: frequently asked questions
Common questions about EV vs gas in 2025
Bottom line: is an EV worth it over gas?
If you boil the EV vs gas debate down to a single idea, it’s this: EVs front‑load more of your costs into the purchase price and reward you slowly, mile after mile, while gas cars spread costs out through fuel and maintenance. In 2025, with gas prices moderate and electricity costs rising, the advantage isn’t universal, but for the right driver, it’s still substantial.
If you drive a lot, have reliable home charging, and care about smooth, quiet performance and lower emissions, a well‑chosen EV, especially a used one with verified battery health, can beat a comparable gas car on daily cost and driving enjoyment. If you rarely drive, lack charging access, or road‑trip constantly, an efficient gas or hybrid still makes a strong case.
When you’re ready to explore EV options without guesswork, Recharged can help you compare real cars with transparent battery data, fair pricing, financing, trade‑in options, and expert guidance from first click to delivery. EV or gas, the goal is the same: a car that fits your life, your budget, and the way you actually drive.
